Positioning Grid Plot

Posted by:

|

On:

|

Our Mission: May’s mission is to provide a funky, fresh, and celebrational experience for those looking to alleviate stress, relax, reconnect, and have fun.

Our target client: The ideal clients for May’s Rentals are women ages 25-55 with an income moderately higher than the nation average cost of living within the US. More information on this is provided here.

Positioning Statement: May’s Realty offers fully online transactions at a moderately affordable cost. We focus on urban, adult vacationing that features design as accommodation appealing enough to even ‘spend the night in’. Our full-functional units allow groups to spend quality time together, without the overwhelming cramp and clutter getting in the way.

Points of Contact: Accurate, high-quality listing photos, fast and helpful responses, quick and easy transactions, constant communication before, during, and after the stay, clean and stocked properties. These are the points of contact (whether they be direct or indirect) that will help set May’s Rentals apart from other vacation hospitality offerings and services.

Modes of Communication: All listing photos will feature May’s brand logo (which is broken down and explained here). May’s will also have a full-functioning independent website (apart from Airbnb and other third-party rental listing services) explaining our brand and our mission. The priority is to provide good service to our renters, as well as beautifully crafted offerings that uphold our brand image.

(PowerPoint Makeovers: The Airbnb Pitch Deck| The Beautiful Blog).

The image above shows a pre-developed positioning grid plot for Airbnb that was found online. This grid plot is being shown first, as it is important to understand where Airbnb falls among alternative vacation rental listing sites. This is because May’s Rentals (especially in the early stages of operation, prior to extensive expansion and growth efforts) will focus its marketing and listing efforts and cost allocation on the Airbnb platform (Lile, 2019).

This positioning grid plot ranks Airbnb against competitors on the factors of affordability (high vs. low cost) and online vs. offline transactions (Lile, 2019). The actual transaction between hosts and renters takes place directly through the Airbnb site. This allows many users to feel a sense of safety and trust, as these payments are proven to be easy and highly secure (Woodward, 2024). Features like this put Airbnb very high into the online access scale, opposed to competitors that complete transaction offline. Competitors shown to the left of the graph may have competitive advantage over Airbnb listings, as they (on average) are more affordable than booking with Airbnb (Lile, 2019). Airbnb can counteract this by having more promoting diversity, innovation, and higher quality within their offerings.

The two positioning grid plots shown above were generated on behalf of May’s Rentals. These graphics depict where May’s Rentals stands amongst other groups of hosts/listing within the Airbnb website. The first plot compares listing forms on the scale of ‘family-focused’ to ‘adult-focused’ and ‘a place to stay’ vs. ‘design/appeal’. May’s Rentals falls closer to the ‘adult-focused’ end of the scale; however, it is not as adult-centric as couples getaway listings because while the properties may not necessarily appeal to families, they still have the ability to host families. May’s Rentals ranks high on the ‘design/appeal’ scale, as their primary brand is centered around funky and fresh designs, including features, such as themed rooms. This is something that listings within specific target groups of guests do not necessarily feature, so ‘a place to stay’ refers to places that serve the basic needs of their clients (they are safe and clean but not particularly visually appealing or aesthetically decorated).

The second plot positioned May’s as being very ‘urban’, opposed to ‘rural’ on the scale. May’s properties will be featured in cities (focused on the East Coast), which sets them apart from other listings that are featured within rural areas. As May’s properties will be decorated featuring cool, themed designs, they will be a very inviting space for guests to potentially take pictures in or spend a night in to celebrate amongst one another. However, since they are likewise features in urban areas, there is a lot of things to explore, as well as extensive night-life options, which is why May’s Rentals is positioned towards the center point between ‘outdoor-centric’ and ‘indoor-centric’. ‘Outdoor-centric’ refers to listings proposed to those who are looking to explore the great outdoors during their stay (spending minimal time, primarily sleeping, within the property itself). ‘Indoor-centric’ refers more to those who need this space as a peaceful getaway, such as May’s target client of old-time friends turned mothers looking to spend a weekend away from their children.

These graphs primarily depict how May’s Rental listing will stand out as a brand amongst other listings on the Airbnb site, which are typically not branded as a line of properties, but mainly tied to the host’s profile themself.

The above positioning grid plot highlights some of the key desires/frustrations identified by May’s ideal client sample group. Affordability is always wanted, as many clients within the target group have children, and others still remain in the beginning stages of their career. However, it is not the top priority, as renting from May’s can be seen as a splurge or may be reserved for special occasions/gatherings. In addition, the quality of May’s properties (especially aesthetically speaking) is higher than other traditional offerings. In addition, May’s targets clients with a moderate level of disposable income for purposed, such as vacationing/funding a stay with May’s! May’s properties also offer more space and private common spaces than other hospitality forms, such as hotels. May’s properties will primarily be apartment or condominium offerings, making them less spacious than single-home or duplex offerings, but more spacious and independent than hotel offerings.

See all references for this content here!

5 responses to “Positioning Grid Plot”

  1. Tonya Thomas Avatar
    Tonya Thomas

    Hi Maddie,

    This project really doubles down on your ideal client project. I enjoyed seeing the competition chart. It may be a good thing to go back and show where you expect to compete with the more well known competition. Visuals often grab attention, so it would be good to see May’s rentals carving out space on competition chart. Great work!

    1. Madelynn Duffield Avatar
      Madelynn Duffield

      Tonya,
      Thank you! Yes, I think I could develop more detailed positioning plots to show local competition for individual properties in the future.
      Best,
      Maddie

  2. Kylie Baker Avatar
    Kylie Baker

    Hi Maddie,

    Thank you for sharing this insightful overview of May’s Rentals and where it lies on a positioning grid. The mission to provide a “funky, fresh, and celebrational experience” is compelling and speaks to a niche market that values both relaxation and fun. However, it might be beneficial to explicitly mention in the mission statement that the properties themselves are what’s being offered to clients. This could help potential clients immediately understand that May’s Rentals is providing unique accommodations as it took me a few re-reads to fully understand what exactly was being “sold”.

    Your focus on urban, adult-centric vacationing with a design appeal is a strong differentiator, especially in a crowded market like Airbnb. Given the emphasis on the “funky” and visually striking interiors, have you considered marketing these properties for photo shoots or to Instagram influencers? The design-forward spaces could attract a broader audience, particularly those looking for visually appealing backdrops for content creation. I wonder if offering additional “add ons” like 1 hour photo shoots or props for photo shoots would be beneficial, not only financially but by providing professional graphics for customers to post on their social media, expanding your reach?

    I also noticed the regional focus on the East Coast, which is a smart move. Could you provide more details on how far apart the units will be located? Understanding the proximity of properties could be key for guests who may want to visit multiple locations during their stay.

    Lastly, I appreciate the clear positioning of May’s Rentals on the design/appeal and urban/rural scales, particularly the acknowledgment that affordability, while important, isn’t the top priority for your target market. It’s evident that you’ve thought carefully about where May’s fits within the broader vacation rental landscape, and I think this thoughtful positioning will serve you well.

    Looking forward to learning more!

    1. Madelynn Duffield Avatar
      Madelynn Duffield

      Kylie,
      Yes, I think influencer marketing could be a great tactic here! I have also considered the idea of potential partnerships (we would pay the influencers, as they already have a customer base, and we do not) with influencers that are artist. Our properties could feature their work, and they could thus promote us.
      Best,
      Maddie

  3. Taelor Eyre Avatar
    Taelor Eyre

    Hi Maddie,

    Great analysis! I love your concept of themed rooms and going all out on the design and aesthetic for your renting experience. I personally love when airbnbs have touches like this. I see a lot of similarities between May’s rentals and some of the rental experiences in Nashville, Scottsdale, and Palm Springs. I think May’s will be unique because all properties offered will have the themed, fun experience; versus having to find/sort through airbnb to find the few homes with the similar experience. I’m excited to see where May’s Rentals goes!

    Cheers,
    Taelor